| Award Year | Recipient | Grad Year | Award |
| 1956 | Alfred C. Snead | 1907 | Service to Society |
| 1957 | Margaret J. Wearley | 1933 | Service to Society |
| 1958 | John F. Gates | 1938 | Service to Society |
| 1959 | John Bechtel, Sr. | 1929 | Service to Society |
| 1960 | Milton Baker | 1939 | Service to Society |
| 1961 | Robert R. Brown | 1910 | Service to Society |
| 1962 | V. Raymond Edman | 1922 | Service to Society |
| 1963 | Harold M. Freligh | 1920 | Service to Society |
| 1964 | Herbert A. Jackson | 1919 | Service to Society |
| 1965 | David C. Kopp | 1919 | Service to Society |
| 1966 | Ralph G. Caldwell | 1945 | Service to Society |
| 1967 | William F. Smalley | 1917 | Service to Society |
| 1968 | Marie Ziemer | 1943 | Service to Society |
| 1969 | Clyde Taylor | 1924 | Service to Society |
| 1970 | Mabel M. Francis | 1908 | Service to Society |
| 1971 | Colver J. Mason | 1928 | Service to Society |
| 1972 | Herman H. Hazlett | 1924 | Service to Society |
| 1973 | Merrill C. Tenney | 1924 | Service to Society |
| 1974 | H. Robert Cowles | 1949 | Service to Society |
| 1975 | Robert B. Ekvall | 1922 | Service to Society |
| 1976 | Marion B. Howe | 1948 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1976 | Kenneth P. Berg | 1944 | Service to Society |
| 1977 | C. Donald McKaig | 1939 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1977 | Benjamin L. Armstrong | 1945 | Service to Society |
| 1978 | Harold W. Boon | 1931 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1978 | Nathan Bailey | 1931 | Service to Society |
| 1979 | Gilbert H. Johnson | 1925 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1979 | Louis L. King | 1938 | Service to Society |
| 1980 | Brad N. Hess, Sr. | 1942 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1980 | T. Grady Mangham | 1943 | Service to Society |
| 1981 | Elizabeth Jackson | 1938 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1981 | David J. Fant | 1930 | Service to Society |
| 1982 | Thomas P. Bailey | 1939 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1982 | Paul Freed | 1944 | Service to Society |
| 1983 | John F. Taylor | 1943 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1983 | Howard O. Jones | 1944 | Service to Society |
| 1984 | T. Robert Brewer | 1942 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1984 | William W. Kerr | 1944 | Service to Society |
| 1984 | Marion N. Kerr | 1944 | Service to Society |
| 1985 | Elizabeth M. Aines | 1950 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1985 | May K. Leo | 1952 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1985 | F. Ruth Bailey | 1947 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1985 | Joseph E. Bersche | 1951 | Service to Society |
| 1985 | Marilyn Wertz Dugan | 1952 | Service to Society |
| 1986 | Sunny O. Ng | 1966 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1986 | Oddy N. Olsen | 1955 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1986 | Elvin P. Jackson | 1954 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1986 | William J. Newell | 1949 | Service to Society |
| 1986 | Beatrice Bush Bixler | 1942 | Service to Society |
| 1987 | Jack F. Shepherd | 1943 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1987 | W. Eugene Evans | 1944 | Service to Society |
| 1987 | Beverly M. Boon | 1965 | Service to Society |
| 1988 | Edward Turner | 1962 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1988 | Harry M. Taylor | 1935 | Service to Society |
| 1989 | Donald N. Hammond | 1974 | Service to Society |
| 1989 | John S. Sawin | 1935 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1990 | Richard O. Eldred | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 1990 | Mary Canberg | Faculty | Service to Society |
| 1990 | Maurice R. Irvin | 1951 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1991 | Barbara A. Shiffer | Staff | Service to Nyack College |
| 1991 | Beatrice E. Turner | 1958 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1991 | Harold M. Best | 1953 | Service to Society |
| 1991 | Gordon M. Cathy | 1949 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1992 | Donald V. Seibert | Faculty/Trustee | Service to Nyack College |
| 1992 | Tite Tienou | 1971 | Service to Society |
| 1992 | Anne Moore | 1953 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1993 | Augustine Mascaro, Jr. | 1962 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1993 | Betty M. Nicholson | 1949 | Service to Society |
| 1993 | Joseph A. Nicholson | 1950 | Service to Society |
| 1993 | G. Linwood and Elsie M. Barney | 1947/1947 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1994 | Esther Long | 1961 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1994 | John A. Oostdyk | 1969 | Service to Society |
| 1994 | Walter M. Caston | 1938 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1995 | David K. Huttar | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 1995 | William H. Lothrop | 1938 | Service to Society |
| 1995 | Richard W. Bailey | 1949 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1996 | Ralph G. Ellenberger | 1955 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1996 | Frank A. Nagle | 1934 | Service to Society |
| 1996 | David L. and Ruth C. Rambo | 1957/1960 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1997 | David A. Pletincks | 1964 | Service to Nyack College |
| 1997 | Phyllis E. Taylor | 1944 | Service to Society |
| 1997 | Paul L. Alford | 1951 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1998 | Donal E. Nilsson | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 1998 | Serge and Donna Duss | 1972/1972 | Service to Society |
| 1998 | Clifford and Marlene Westergren | 1956/1956 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1999 | Eldon G. Woodcock | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 1999 | Lewis P. Bird | 1956 | Service to Society |
| 1999 | Thomas H. and Donna J. Stebbins | 1956/1953 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 1999 | Stephen R. Goodwin | 1981 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2000 | Elio Cuccaro | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 2000 | Henry G. Gathagan | 1957 | Service to Society |
| 2000 | Anthony G. Bollback | 1943 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2000 | William J. Opperman | 1983 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2000 | D. Dewitt Wasson | 1943 | Service to Music |
| 2000 | Pamela Harmon Lima | 1977 | Service to Education |
| 2000 | Alex Leonovich | 1944 | Service to Community |
| 2001 | Kevin and Christine Buel | 1988/1980 | Service to Nyack College |
| 2001 | Charles and Ingrid Davis | 1982/1983 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2001 | Robert Niklaus | 1955 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2001 | Leslie Andrews | 1966 | Service to Education |
| 2001 | Shaker Samuels | 1979 | Service to Society |
| 2001 | Ed Davis | 1973 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2001 | Chuck and Betty Pugh | 1947/1946 | Service to Music |
| 2001 | Mark Wellman | Trustee | Service to Nyack College |
| 2002 | Alfred Townsend | 1969 | Service to Music |
| 2002 | Kenneth and Carolyn Van Kurin | 1958 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2002 | Richard B. Pease | 1957 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2003 | Kenneth and Ruth Wackes | 1961/1959 | Service to Music |
| 2003 | Brad Jenkins | 1982 | Service to Society |
| 2003 | Bill Weisenbach | 1966 | Service to Education |
| 2003 | Christine Webb | 2003 | Service to Education (K-12) |
| 2003 | Helen Evans | 1949 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2003 | Joyce Simons | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 2004 | Bryan Burrell | 1982 | Service to Nyack College |
| 2005 | Barb Shiffer | Staff | Service to Nyack College |
| 2005 | David and Betzi Schroeder | 1968 | Vision, Leadership and Legacy Award |
| 2006 | John Mwangi | 1978 | Service to the Kingdom and Society |
| 2007 | David Kennedy | 1962 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2007 | Thelma Braun | 1944 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2007 | David Turk | 1975 | Service to Nyack College |
| 2007 | Clarence “Beef” Castel (1928-2007) | 1956 | Alumni Legacy Award |
| 2008 | Howard O. Jones | 1944 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2008 | Stephen D. Julian | 1983 | Service to Nyack College |
| 2008 | Ronald H. Julian, Sr. | 1956 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2008 | Elizabeth “Betty” Aines (1922-2006) | 1952 | Alumni Legacy Award |
| 2009 | Timothy J. Albright | 1986 | International Service to The CMA |
| 2009 | David K. Smith | 1989 | North American Service to The CMA |
| 2009 | Glenn Koponen | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 2009 | Ernie Armoogam (1971-2008) | 1997 | Alumni Legacy Award |
| 2009 | Rev. Gunther Kamphausen | 1959 | Service to the Kingdom and Society |
| 2009 | Margaret “Peg” Bowen | ESL Faculty, NYC | Service to Nyack College |
| 2010 | Dennis Krajacic | 1975 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2010 | Philip Renicks | 1965 | Service to Christian Education |
| 2010 | Alfred Lee Hearn | 1965 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2010 | James D. Gamble, Jr. | 2002 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2011 | Timothy D. and Mrs. Shelly Crouch | 1985/1986 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2011 | Janet A. Howard | 1960 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2012 | Chad Bullock | 2011 | Young Alumnus |
| 2012 | Ronald and Beverly Ruegsegger | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 2012 | Woodford and Charlotte Stemple | 1962/1961 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2012 | Ralph Trainer | 1982 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2012 | Susanna L. Schneider | 1983 | Award for Global Engagement |
| 2012 | Ann M. McCarthy | 1983 | Award for Global Engagement |
| 2012 | Miguel A. Sanchez | Faculty | Award for Intentional Diversity |
| 2012 | Gregory P. Hauter | 1987 | Award for Social Relevance |
| 2012 | Donald L. Paine | 1971 | Award for Personal Transformation |
| 2013 | David W. Graf | 1984 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2013 | Trent and Sharon Thornton | 1977/1978 | Int’l Ministry and Service to The CMA |
| 2013 | Rex Boda | 1958 | Lifetime Achievement Award |
| 2013 | Christopher A. Yount | 1984 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2013 | Kelvin L. Walker | 1988 | Service to Nyack College |
| 2013 | Richard A. Villodas | 2003 | Young Alumnus |
| 2014 | Douglas Prentice | 1984 | Award for Global Engagement |
| 2014 | David G. and Linda McKechnie | 1963/1964 | Service to the Kingdom |
| 2014 | Benjamin D. Raber | 2007 | Young Alumnus |
| 2014 | Charles Hammond, Jr. | Faculty | Service to Nyack College |
| 2014 | Roy Kirton | 2003 | Service to Society |
| 2014 | Richard Farmer | 1975 | President’s Award |
| 2015 | Ronald C. and Wanda F. Walbon | 1984/1984 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2015 | Ty Buckman | 1990 | Award for Academic Excellence |
| 2015 | Carol Belec | 1965 | Award for Global Engagement |
| 2015 | Joseph and Beverly Miller | 1985/1985 | Award for Global Engagement |
| 2015 | Josh and Jaclyn Blanchard | 2010/2009 | Young Alumnus/a |
| 2015 | Thomas Donworth | Faculty | Service to Nyack |
| 2015 | Dorothy Hostetter | 1957 | Lifetime Achievement Award |
| 2016 | Douglas Conley | 1976 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2016 | Philip Chorlian | 1991 | Service to the Kingdom of God |
| 2016 | Holly Nichols | 2006 | Young Alumna |
| 2016 | L. Jay Mapstone | 1954 | Lifetime Achievement Award |
| 2017 | Stephen M. McKnight | 1987 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2017 | Lauri A. McKnight | 1987 | Service to The Christian and Missionary Alliance |
| 2017 | Michele M. Blanck | 2005 | Service to Nyack College |
| 2017 | Justin J. Thornton | 2007 | Service to the Kingdom of God |
| 2017 | Abena McAllister | 2007 | Service to Society |
| 2017 | Christopher J. Smith | 2010 | Young Alumnus of the Year |
| 2018 | Rev. Dr. Mia Chang M.Div. | 2007 | Alumna of the Year for Servant Leadership |